New York City: hot, sticky, crowded, and beloved, but not by me
Friday, July 31st, 2009
When it’s been 2 ½ years since you went to New York City, and you live full-time in a place where you’ve got a corn field around the corner and a dairy farm down the road, there’s a lot to forget about what is arguably the world’s most storied metropolis.
A good friend from Vienna was visiting last week, and I offered to take him into the city for a day, since it had been, as mentioned, 2 ½ years for me (last time I went I was one month pregnant and spent a great day at the Museum of Modern Art) and over 10 years for him. There’s a train from here that takes 1 ½ hours to get to Penn Station, which doesn’t seem that long when you consider that you step on a platform in an open field, with birds cheering you on your way, and step off into a thrumming, ever-moving, overpopulated and overheated sea of people.
Unfortunately, the train engine broke down halfway. After 40 minutes trying to fix it, the dispatchers decided the train behind us could push us to our destination but it would have to go local. We’d been on an express. Half an hour later whatever virus was affecting our train proceeded to infect the new one, and the journey – peppered with apologies from the staff – took 3 ½ hours. The conversation my friend and I had involved a whole lot of comparisons with the European train system and how very much like a 3rd world country the United States is becoming. Needless to say we ventured off into the lack of universal health care.
When we broke down the second time and I looked out an open door at a dusty platform with hot, rather resigned looking people scattered around, it reminded me so much of my time living in Soviet Russia that I almost searched for someone selling paper-like cones of soft marozhonoe ice cream.
But we made it eventually, disembarking into the city that I think you have to love with your whole heart if you’re to live in it peaceably.
It was nearly 90 degrees out, and brutally sticky, and so crowded I could hardly breathe. We took a subway downtown, looking for a restaurant near Washington Square Park. That mission failed, as we called the place and found out it was actually in Brooklyn (nothing like “You’re where? That’s in Manhatten. We’re in Brooklyn,” to make you feel like the most idiotic kind of doltish tourist).
So we do what you do in New York: walked around, watching people and the hectic, vibrant, congested life its residents live. In Washington Square Park children (and often their overheated parents) jumped and ran through the fountain to cool off under the beating sun (pictured above). Musicians vied for attention: a bagpiper, a folk guitarist, and a rather good young punk band with a vintage feel to their music.
I couldn’t live here, I kept thinking. But then the thought moderated itself. “I could only live here if I really, really loved it,” I told my friend. “You’d have to love New York heart and soul to put up with all this.” ‘This’ being the heat, the heaving crowds, the decrepit, stinking subway stations, the dusty, overused parks. I don’t love it. I don’t think I can. But there is just enough glimmer of thrill and satisfaction in its residents that I can see how people do fall in love with the Big Apple.

Sometimes it really does pay to check out your own backyard. I am perfectly aware that the Hudson Valley county I live in is chock-a-block with history and stories, but don’t always pay attention. Goshen, New York, is a case in point. Sure, I knew it had some history related to horse-racing, but mostly it was the place where I got my bike fixed and bought decent wine.
That’s changed. While waiting for a quick meeting with our lawyer, my husband, son, and I, along with a visiting friend, wandered around the ample-sized village for about an hour, munching on lunch and looking at the architecture. The place is full of surprises. We stumbled upon this plaque, for example, on a side-street, and learned from it that Noah Webster, of dictionary fame, used to teach here in a two-room schoolhouse in the 1700s. My county’s full of such plaques, mostly relating to the Revolutionary War. I should pay more attention.
The Trotters Museum, as it’s sometimes called, hosted harness racing’s most important event, The Hambletonian, up until 1956 — think Belmont Stakes. It is still a working racetrack. And, unlike most racetracks, you can walk through the grounds and peek in the stables at the gorgeous thoroughbreds cooling their heels between races. Hooves, I mean.
If you stay for a few hours or a couple days, I can highly recommend Dave’s BBQ down on Main Street, which looks a bit like it might be a chain, but in fact serves fantastic Southern-style barbecue, collards, and cornbread (including vegetarian options), made as often as possible from local ingredients and is seriously tasty. You can also check out what I think of as the
The main town green is attached to a massive stone Presbyterian church, and is the location for town events (such as Fourth of July celebrations) and the Friday Farmer’s Market, where you can buy everything from produce to pies to pickles. Running out the back end of the church property is a long row of historical buildings built in a variety of aesthetically pleasing architectural forms and known as “Lawyer’s Row,” for the sheer quantities of law offices they contain. 

This mythical memoir is written with a touch that tells you it’s very likely based on Barbara Bonfigli’s own travels, and she could have easily written a travel book about her experiences on a small Greek island. Indeed, Bonfigli is an avowed travel addict and a published travel writer. She says of herself, “Maps are my recreational drug of choice,” a statement that I’m sure has many of us laughing and ruefully recognizing ourselves at the same time.